The St. Croix Valley is one of the most desirable places to live in the Twin Cities area — and for good reason. With riverfront charm, family-friendly neighborhoods, and beautiful natural surroundings, there’s a perfect community here for everyone.
But if you’re choosing between Stillwater, Hudson, or Lake Elmo, how do you know which one truly fits your lifestyle? Let’s explore what makes each area unique — from home styles to local amenities — so you can find your perfect match.
Stillwater: Historic Charm Meets Small-Town Living
Known as the Birthplace of Minnesota, Stillwater offers timeless beauty, tree-lined streets, and a lively historic downtown along the St. Croix River.
Why people love it:
-
Walkable main street filled with boutique shops, restaurants, and coffee spots.
-
Annual events like Lumberjack Days and the Ice Castles keep the community buzzing year-round.
-
A blend of historic homes, charming Victorians, and new construction on the outskirts.
-
Top-rated schools and a strong sense of community.
The vibe: Relaxed, historic, and community-oriented — perfect for those who want small-town warmth without sacrificing modern convenience.
💡 Pro tip: Buyers searching for Stillwater homes for sale often fall in love with the river views and character-filled neighborhoods that make this town stand out.
Hudson: Vibrant Riverfront and Wisconsin Value
Just across the bridge, Hudson, Wisconsin delivers scenic beauty, great schools, and a lively downtown — often with more house for your money.
Why people love it:
-
Gorgeous riverfront dining, local breweries, and a strong arts and food scene.
-
Quick access to I-94 for an easy Twin Cities commute.
-
Lower property taxes than in many nearby Minnesota communities.
-
A variety of housing options, from downtown condos to new developments on the outskirts.
The vibe: Active, social, and welcoming — a great fit for anyone who enjoys being near the water and wants a balance between small-town comfort and city access.
💡 Pro tip: Hudson WI real estate continues to attract Minnesota buyers looking for affordability and lifestyle all in one package.
Lake Elmo: Suburban Space with Modern Appeal
If you’re after more elbow room and newer homes, Lake Elmo might be calling your name. Once a quiet rural area, it’s now one of the east metro’s most sought-after communities — without losing its peaceful charm.
Why people love it:
-
Expansive parks and trails, including the beloved Lake Elmo Park Reserve.
-
Spacious lots and newer construction, including energy-efficient designs.
-
Excellent schools and close proximity to Stillwater, Woodbury, and downtown St. Paul.
-
A relaxed, upscale suburban feel with room to grow.
The vibe: Tranquil and family-friendly — ideal for those who value space, nature, and modern comforts.
💡 Pro tip: Lake Elmo neighborhoods offer the perfect balance of privacy and convenience, making it a top choice for move-up buyers.
Quick Comparison: Finding Your Fit
| Community | Vibe | Average Home Price | Commute to St. Paul | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stillwater | Historic & charming | $$$ | ~35 min | Small-town lovers |
| Hudson | Riverfront & vibrant | $$ | ~30 min | Value seekers & commuters |
| Lake Elmo | Quiet & suburban | $$$$ | ~25 min | Space seekers |
(Data based on 2025 local MLS trends)
So, Which One Is Right for You?
Each of these St. Croix Valley towns offers something truly special:
-
Stillwater for character and charm.
-
Hudson for affordability and energy.
-
Lake Elmo for space and modern living.
Your perfect fit depends on your priorities — and we’d love to help you find it.
Or, if you’re ready to start touring homes, contact us today and let’s explore which community feels like home.
